• Home
  • Variable vs Fixed: The 2025 Reality Check for Canadian Borrowers
Variable vs Fixed: The 2025 Reality Check for Canadian Borrowers
By Team Breaking Bank profile image Team Breaking Bank
4 min read

Variable vs Fixed: The 2025 Reality Check for Canadian Borrowers

Are You Betting on Stability or Flexibility?

In 2025, choosing between a fixed or variable mortgage isn’t just about preference—it’s about risk, timing, and how much uncertainty you can stomach.

After two years of wild rate swings, inflation surprises, and mixed signals from the Bank of Canada, borrowers are stepping into a murkier landscape. The cost of choosing wrong could mean hundreds of dollars a month—or tens of thousands over the life of your mortgage.

This article breaks down what’s changed, what to watch for, and how to make the right move for your financial goals.

Where Rates Sit in Mid-2025

Let’s ground this in the current numbers (as of June 2025):

  • Bank of Canada policy rate: 2.75%
  • Prime rate: ~4.95%

Variable Rates:

  • Insured: ~4.04% to 4.30%
  • Conventional: ~4.30% to 4.79%

5-Year Fixed Rates:

  • Insured: 4.04% (BC only) to 4.24%
  • Conventional: 4.36% to 4.59%

The gap between fixed and variable has narrowed—but two more expected BoC rate cuts could shift the math again before year-end.

Choose Based on Strategy, Not Guesswork

There’s no universally “right” answer. The better question is—what fits your situation, timeline, and tolerance for uncertainty?

Go Variable If...

  • You believe rates will keep falling through 2025–2026
  • You can handle some payment fluctuation
  • You might break your mortgage early (e.g., sell, refinance, relocate)

Go Fixed If...

  • You want budget certainty and payment predictability
  • You think inflation might flare back up
  • You’re staying put for the full term

Fixed vs Variable: What It Actually Costs

Let’s compare a $400,000 mortgage over a 25-year amortization.

5-Year Fixed at 4.59%

  • Monthly payment: $2,234
  • Total interest (5 years): $85,743

5-Year Variable at 4.30%

  • Monthly payment: $2,169
  • Total interest (5 years): $80,190

Monthly savings: $65 Total 5-year savings: $3,900

These figures assume rates stay flat for the full 5-year term. If the Bank of Canada cuts rates further—as many economists expect—the savings from going variable could increase significantly.

The Hidden Factor: Breaking Your Mortgage

Here’s where many borrowers get blindsided.

Roughly 6 in 10 Canadians don’t keep their mortgage for the full 5-year term. Life happens—jobs change, families grow, plans evolve.

Fixed-rate penalties are notoriously hard to predict. They're based on the Interest Rate Differential (IRD), which compares your original rate to the lender’s current rate for the remaining term. Depending on timing and your lender, these penalties can range from a few thousand to over $20,000.

Variable-rate penalties, by contrast, are simple: 3 months’ interest.

  • On a $400,000 mortgage at 4.30%, that’s about $4,300.

If there’s even a chance you’ll need to exit early, that penalty difference could easily erase any “savings” from locking into a fixed rate.

The Fine Print Matters—A Lot

Rate isn’t the only thing that matters. In many cases, the structure of your mortgage—and the fine print—can impact your long-term finances more than a quarter point in interest.

Here are a few features to look for:

  • Portability: If you lock into a fixed-rate mortgage, make sure it’s portable, especially across provinces. Without portability, moving could trigger massive break penalties—even if you’re buying another home.
  • Prepayment Privileges: Can you make extra payments without penalty? Some lenders allow lump-sum payments or double-up options, helping you pay off your mortgage faster.
  • Blend and Extend Options: Can you refinance into a new term without triggering a penalty if rates drop?

A great mortgage broker doesn’t just hunt for the lowest rate—they help you navigate these options and make sure your mortgage fits your life, not just your spreadsheet.

Where the Wind Is Blowing

Big bank economists are still forecasting two more BoC cuts by the end of 2025, potentially bringing variable rates closer to the 4.00% mark by early 2026. That gives variable-rate borrowers a potential tailwind—if they’re willing to ride it out.

Fixed rates, on the other hand, are expected to hold relatively steady, since they follow bond yields more than central bank decisions.

Translation:

  • Variable has room to fall.
  • Fixed is likely near its short-term floor.

2025 Reality Check: What’s Right for You?

  • Fixed: Best if you’re risk-averse and want predictability.
  • Variable: Better if you’re planning ahead, value flexibility, or expect rates to drop.
  • Structure > Rate: The “cheapest rate” isn’t always the smartest choice.

Consider the Hybrid Approach: The Best of Both Worlds

For borrowers torn between stability and flexibility, a hybrid mortgage could offer the perfect middle ground. This structure splits your mortgage into two portions—typically 50/50 fixed and variable—allowing you to lock in part of your loan for predictability while still taking advantage of potential rate drops on the variable side. It’s a strategic hedge: if rates fall, your variable portion benefits; if they rise, your fixed side cushions the impact. Hybrid mortgages also offer more psychological comfort, helping borrowers sleep at night without fully committing to either extreme. It's a smart option for those who want balance without placing all their chips on one rate bet.

Bottom Line: In today’s market, the mortgage with the right features—portability, prepayment flexibility, manageable penalties—can save you more than a 0.50% rate cut ever could.

Before you sign, talk to a mortgage pro who understands the fine print and can match you with a mortgage that actually fits your plans.

Read Next